Soups and Salads

All You Can Eat Salad Bar
A wide selection of fresh ingredients to
satisfy the most discriminating salad lover. No sharing please | 7.95  | Add one trip to any sandwich for 3.50
All You Can Eat Soup and Salad Bar
One bowl of French Onion Soup may be substituted for all you can eat soup | 9.50
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce and Caesar dressing tossed with homemade croutons | 7.95
Spinach Salad
Fresh spinach, bacon, mushrooms, boiled egg, Swiss cheese and our homemade croûtons. Comes with hot bacon dressing unless
otherwise specified | 9.75
Green Leaf Salad
Fresh salad greens and vegetables.  Served with your choice of dressing |  7.95
The Light Plate 
Choose blackened or grilled chicken or salmon. Served with freshly sliced fruit, celery and carrot sticks and cottage cheese | Chicken 9.95 | Salmon 10.95
Vegetable | Everyday
Broccoli | Monday & Tuesday
Potato | Wednesday & Thursday
New England Clam Chowder | Friday
Cup 3.25 or Bowl 4.75
French Onion Soup
Everyday | 5.50
Everyday in winter | Cup 3.25 or Bowl 4.75 | Currently out of season
Add Soup to any sandwich
Cup 1.75 | Bowl 3.50 | Chili or French Onion 4

Burgers & Wraps

The Classic  
Angus beef or 100% vegetarian gardenburger on a toasted brioche bun.  | 7.95
Applewood Bacon Cheddar Burger
Smoked applewood bacon and cheddar cheese piled on top of Angus beef or gardenburger.  Dress it up any way you’d like | 9.95
Pimento Cheese Burger 
Homemade pimento cheese smothered on top of a 1/3 pound pattie with mixed greens and sliced tomato |  9.95
Cowboy Burger
Cheddar Cheese, Homemade Onion Rings, and BBQ Sauce on a toasted brioche bun | 9.95
new | Black & Bleu
Blackened and covered in our creamy bleu cheese, bacon, and garlic spread.  Served with mixed greens and tomato | 9.95
Butcher Burger
Sautéed mushrooms, onions and melted Swiss cheese topped with mixed greens and sliced tomato on a toasted brioche bun | 9.95
Southwestern Chicken Wrap
Spicy grilled chicken, pepper jack, cheddar, onions, tomatoes, lettuce and a Southwestern style cheese spread. Served on a sun-dried tomato wrap | 9.95
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Our grilled chicken Caesar salad served on a whole wheat wrap.  Just choose blackened or grilled chicken | 9.95
BBQ Chicken Wrap
Seasoned grilled chicken, applewood bacon, southwestern style cream cheese spread and cheddar cheese. Drizzled with barbecue sauce on a whole wheat wrap | 9.95
Fresh Salmon Croissant
Blackened or grilled and served with lettuce, tomato and a side of ranch dressing | 10.95
Turkey Croissant
Thinly sliced turkey with sprouts, tomatoes, Swiss cheese  | 9.95
Roast Beef Croissant
Thinly sliced, rare  certified Angus roast beef on a toasted croissant with your choice of cheese.  Served with au jus. | 9.95

These menu items are cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.


The Pepper’s Sub
Salami, bologna, ham, turkey, lettuce,  tomatoes, pepper cheese and a special sauce
Half  5.50 Whole 8.95
The Jean Lawson 
Turkey, marinated mushrooms, onions, green peppers and pepper cheese on a kaiser roll
Half  5.50 Whole  8.95
Certified Angus corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and thousand island on grilled rye bread | Half  5.50  Whole  8.95
French Dip
Certified Angus roast beef on a sub roll, served with a cup of hot au jus. Add Swiss or provolone for free! Great with horseradish.
Half  5.50  Whole  8.95
The New Yorker
Hot Certified Angus pastrami piled on a kaiser with red onion, spicy mustard and topped with Swiss cheese | Half  5.50  Whole 8.95
Sprout Sandwich
Alfalfa sprouts, onions, green peppers,
tomatoes, Swiss cheese and mayonnaise on wheat bread | Half  5.50  Whole  8.95
Meatball Sub
Meatballs in tomato sauce with provolone cheese on a sub roll | Half 5.50  Whole 8.95
The Club
Turkey, ham, bacon, cheddar, Swiss, lettuce, tomato and mayo layered on wheat or white toast | 9.95
new | PBLT
Applewood smoked bacon, ripe tomatoes, and mixed greens with pimento cheese served on your choice of bread | 8.95
Custom Grilled Cheese
Choose the cheese.  Choose the bread. Hook it up your way | 5.95
new | Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Blackened chicken breast with pepper jack cheese, lettuce, and tomato. Served on a
brioche roll | 9.95
new | Chicken Club
Grilled or Fried chicken breast with Swiss cheese, applewood bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Served on a brioche roll | 9.95
Southern Fried Catfish Sandwich
Hand-breaded catfish filet deep fried until and served open-faced on a toasted kaiser roll with homemade tarter sauce, lettuce, & tomato | 8.95
Rib-eye Steak Sandwich
Certified Angus Beef rib-eye grilled to your liking and served open-faced on a toasted brioche bun. | 11.95
Blackened Mahi Sandwich
Lightly blackened and grilled Served on a toasted brioche bun topped with mango salsa, lettuce, and sliced tomato | 9.95
Teriyaki Chicken Dip Supreme
Grilled Chicken covered in Canadian Bacon and Provolone  Cheese, served with Teriyaki dipping sauce | 9.95
new | Tuna Melt
Homemade tuna salad covered in melted Swiss cheese on sourdough with sliced tomatoes | 7.95
new | Pesto Caprese
Sourdough grilled with roma tomatoes and fresh mozzarella cheese with fresh basil and pesto sauce.  | 8.95

Flatbread Pizza

Dinner Entrees

new | Baseball Sirloin
A 10 ounce baseball sirloin* wrapped in applewood bacon and char-grilled to your
specification.  Served with your choice of two sides | 16.95
Herb Roasted Salmon
Fresh salmon oven roasted in an herb crust and smothered in creamy florentine sauce
accompanied by fresh sautéed vegetables | 18.95
Cajun Chicken Pasta
This house favorite starts with a blackened chicken breast tossed with penne or fettuccine and fresh veggies in our homemade cream sauce | 16.95
Parmesan Crusted Meatloaf
The secret recipe the Pepper’s grew up loving.  Served with your choice of two sides | 14.95
Spinach Artichoke Ravioli
Homemade Spinach Pasta from Basil’s Fresh Pasta stuffed with our artichoke and cheese blend | 14.95
new | Hand-breaded Fried Chicken
A handbreaded fried chicken breast accompanied by your choice of two sides and stone ground honey mustard | 15.95
new | Southern Fried Catfish
A handbreaded fried Catfish filet accompanied by your choice of two sides and our
homemade tarter sauce | 15.95
Pasta Bowls | 9.99
1. Choose Pasta – Fettuccine, Spaghetti, or Penne
2. Choose Sauce – Homemade Marinara or Alfredo
3. Choose Add-ons – Grilled or Blackened Chicken 3.95 | Grilled or Blackened Salmon 5.95
     Meatballs (4) 3.95 | Sautéed Shrimp (6) 4.95

Homemade Desserts

Carrot Cake
An original Pepper’s favorite since 1975
Slice 5.50 | 2.50 Cupcake
Whole Cake 28.00 | Sheet 45.00
Pepper’s Mud Pie
The best Oreo crust ever filled with coffee ice
cream, topped with fudge, whipped cream,
toasted almonds, and chocolate sauce
Slice 5.50 | Whole Pie 30.00
German Chocolate Cake
Moist chocolate cake smothered in coconut and
pecan topping smothered

Cup Cake 2.50 | Whole Cake 28.00

Sour Cream Apple Pie
Crisp Granny Smith Apples with sweet & tangy
 sour cream filling covered in a crunchy
cinnamon topping
Slice  4.95 | Whole Pie 15.00
Seasonal Cheesecake Selection
Ask your server about this season’s homemade
cheesecake offering.
Slice  5.95 | Whole Cake 30.00
Kids Ice Cream
A scoop of natural vanilla ice cream with
Oreo crumbles | 2.50


Back to Top